John Mateer Leads Heisman Trophy Race After Another Strong Performance
Through three weeks of the 2025 college football season, one name has risen above the rest in the Heisman Trophy conversation: John Mateer, Oklahoma’s dynamic dual-threat quarterback. With 66 points in the most recent Heisman watch voting, Mateer has positioned himself as the frontrunner for college football’s most prestigious individual award. His latest outing against Temple solidified his case, blending playmaking ability with leadership that has elevated the Sooners’ offense to new heights.
Another Balanced Performance
Against Temple, Mateer delivered another performance that showcased why he is one of the most electrifying players in the country. He completed 20 of 34 passes for 282 yards, adding one touchdown and one interception through the air. While his passing wasn’t flawless, it was steady enough to keep Oklahoma’s attack moving. More importantly, he once again proved dangerous with his legs, rushing seven times for 63 yards and a touchdown. His 9.0 yards-per-carry average marked a season-high and demonstrated his growing confidence in making quick reads and attacking defenses on the ground.
This dual-threat capability has become the hallmark of Mateer’s season so far. Defenses may limit him in one area, but he consistently finds ways to impact the game in another. Through three games, Mateer has rushed for a touchdown in each contest, providing a reliable red-zone option and a spark for the Sooners’ offense when drives stall.
The Turnover Question
Of course, no Heisman campaign comes without challenges, and for Mateer, turnovers remain the area of concern. He has thrown an interception in each of Oklahoma’s first three games, including one against Temple that briefly halted the Sooners’ momentum. Cleaning up these mistakes will be crucial as the Sooners move deeper into their Big 12 schedule, where every possession will matter against stiffer competition.
Yet even with those miscues, Mateer’s overall production has outweighed the negatives. His composure after mistakes has been a defining trait. Rather than letting turnovers snowball, he has rebounded with poise, leading scoring drives and flashing the resilience coaches love to see in a leader. That maturity is part of why voters have rewarded him with the Heisman lead at this stage.
Elevating Oklahoma Football
Beyond statistics, Mateer’s impact on the Oklahoma program cannot be overstated. The Sooners entered 2025 seeking stability at the quarterback position, and Mateer has answered the call. His leadership has provided confidence to the offense, and his ability to extend plays has opened up opportunities for both the run game and the receiving corps.
Oklahoma has thrived under his direction, and his play has drawn national attention back to Norman. For a program steeped in quarterback tradition from Baker Mayfield to Kyler Murray and Jalen Hurts Mateer is carrying the torch with performances that keep the Sooners relevant in the national conversation.
Why He’s the Front-Runner
At this stage of the season, Heisman voters are looking for more than just numbers; they want storylines, impact, and consistency. Mateer checks all three boxes.
Production: Through the air and on the ground, he has already shown he can put up big numbers. His ability to create explosive plays with both his arm and legs separates him from many other candidates.
Signature Moments: Mateer’s rushing touchdowns in critical situations have energized his team and given Oklahoma an identity. His highlight plays are already circulating widely on social media, giving him the kind of national exposure necessary for a Heisman run.
Team Success: Perhaps most importantly, the Sooners are winning. A Heisman campaign typically needs to be paired with a top-10 caliber team, and Mateer has positioned Oklahoma right where it needs to be.
The Road Ahead
While Mateer is currently the frontrunner, the Heisman race is never settled in September. Big matchups loom for Oklahoma, and Mateer’s ability to deliver in high-pressure games will define whether he can maintain his lead. Eliminating turnovers will be key, as will continuing to show growth as a passer.
Still, there is every reason to believe he can sustain this pace. His dual-threat ability makes him a nightmare for defensive coordinators, and his early-season performances have built the foundation for a serious campaign. If he keeps scoring with his legs while improving his efficiency through the air, the Heisman could very well be his to lose.
Final Word
John Mateer has all the ingredients of a Heisman Trophy winner: production, leadership, and the ability to carry his team in big moments. With 66 points and the top spot in the latest voting, he stands as the nation’s most compelling candidate three weeks into the season. If he can continue refining his game and cutting down on turnovers, the Sooners may not only have a Heisman winner on their hands, but also a leader capable of guiding them toward championship contention.
Leave a Reply